Sports

SA Rugby’s position on 20-minute red cards as global law trial looms

Debate continues to rage over the controversial 20-minute red which is edging closer to a global trial after World Rugby proposed the law amendment ahead of November’s meeting.

In a series of proposals announced by the governing body last week, the biggest talking point came around the red card.

Should this amendment go through, it will allow teams to replace a player who has been sent off after 20 minutes.

It has been well-backed in the southern hemisphere, with Australia and New Zealand particularly vocal about bringing it in, while European countries remain far more sceptical.

Foot in both camps

But what about South Africa? They effectively have a foot in both camps having aligned their domestic game with the north while also featuring in the Rugby Championship alongside the Wallabies and All Blacks.

According to SA Rugby CEO Rian Oberholzer, they are siding with their historical rivals.

“SARU supports that (20-minute red). A red card spoils the match,” Oberholzer said back in March.

It is a slightly surprising stance given the Springboks in many ways have led the way in improving their discipline, particularly around dangerous tackles.

They have worked hard to adapt to the clampdown in high shots, but Oberholzer would still like to see the 20-minute red card implemented.

“As a spectacle – when you have 14 play against 15 – as someone said, there is a three per cent chance of the 14 winning. I don’t think that is good for the game or the spectators,” he added.

“We, SARU, will support the 20-minute red card – as proposed by World Rugby.”

His words echo that of New Zealand Rugby CEO Mark Robinson, who has long been an advocate of bringing in the law amendment.

“We’re the only sport in the world that creates a mismatch like we do and still expects fans to turn up and pay for it,” Robinson told the Guardian in July.

“I think it’ll be good to see the red card come down in terms of the amount of minutes players spend off the field. We’ve got to keep driving hard at keeping the fan at the very forefront of what we’re doing.

“There are more trials going on but that’s one thing we really believe in. Along with anything that can speed the game up, create more entertainment value and encourage less intervention from TMOs.

“You cannot have your sport stopping for two minutes at a time and taking two hours duration and connect with fans who are coming to games expecting something else.”

The view of the southern hemisphere giants is at complete odds with those in Europe. France have been the most vocal in their criticism of the law and on Monday slammed the decision by World Rugby to put forward the 20-minute red card proposal.

“Although some believe that this rule will promote smoother play, statistics provided by the FFR to World Rugby show that a red card does not systematically mean defeat for the penalised team,” a joint statement from The French Rugby Federation (FFR), the National Rugby League (LNR) and Provale read.

“Indeed, the analysis based on 480 TOP 14 matches and Tier 1 international matches shows that only 60% of the teams receiving a red card lost at the end of the match.”

“For the FFR, the LNR and Provale, the red card is a crucial tool which deters unsportsmanlike behaviour and protects the physical integrity of players.

“Turning this sanction into a temporary expulsion could encourage dangerous behaviour, thereby compromising player safety, which must remain the top priority.

“French professional clubs and national team management emphasise the need to maintain a firm attitude towards unfair play. The red card as a collective sanction aims to preserve balance and fair play, and its reduction to an individual sanction would weaken this essential function.

“Furthermore, this rule would mark an unacceptable step backwards on the measures put in place for several years to reduce head impacts and encourage players to have greater technical mastery in contact.”

Related Posts

Shohei Ohtani’s World Series performance generates a lot of enthusiasm in Japan and draws audiences that are comparable to those in the US

Tokyo (CNN) — Baseball superstar Shohei Ohtani has turned millions of Japanese residents into fans of the Los Angeles Dodgers, so much so that more than a tenth of the country’s…

Lewis Hamilton pide un ‘mensaje de radio’ tras las críticas por agresión a Max Verstappen

Puede que Lewis Hamilton no esté en la pelea por el título durante la temporada 2024 de Fórmula 1, pero después de años de dominio, el piloto de…

เกิดอะไรขึ้น “ศุภณัฏฐ์” กองหน้าทีมชาติไทย แยกทางกับ “โอเอช ลูเวิน”

ศุภณัฏฐ์ เหมือนตา แยกทางกับ โอเอช ลูเวิน วันที่ 31 ตุลาคม 2567 ศุภณัฏฐ์ เหมือนตา แยกทางกับ โอเอช ลูเวิน โดยเป็นการตัดสินใจร่วมทั้งสองฝ่าย ซึ่ง “แบงค์” จะกลับบุรีรัมย์ ยูไนเต็ด ต้นสังกัดเดิม ซึ่งจากนี้จะลงทะเบียน แข่งขัน เอเอฟซี แชมเปียนส์ลีก อีลิท 2024-25 ศุภณัฏฐ์ เปิดเผยว่า…

เรียบร้อย “ฟาน นิสเตลรอย” ตัดสินใจแล้ว อนาคตกับ “แมนยูฯ” หลัง “อโมริม” จ่อนั่งกุนซือถาวร

เรียบร้อย “รุด ฟาน นิสเตลรอย” ตัดสินใจแล้ว อนาคตกับ “แมนยูฯ” หลัง “รูเบน อโมริม” จ่อเป็นกุนซือใหม่แบบถาวร วันที่ 31 ตุลาคม 2567 รุด ฟาน นิสเตลรอย ผู้จัดการทีมชั่วคราวของ แมนเชสเตอร์ ยูไนเต็ด ให้สัมภาษณ์ล่าสุด หลังประเดิมนัดแรกในการคุมทีมแทน เอริก เทน ฮาก ที่โดนปลด พาทีมเปิดบ้านชนะ…

As Shohei Ohtani celebrated winning the World Series, he made a greedy vow to the Dodgers executive

Shohei Ohtani is now a World Series champion, but it’s clear he wants more. Soon after the Los Angeles Dodgers beat the New York Yankees to win the…

Springboks in ‘brilliant position’ to claim World Cup ‘three-peat’ and why All Blacks is no longer rugby’s biggest fixture as stunning November prediction made

Dan Biggar says the All Blacks is no longer the biggest game in international rugby – and Siya Kolisi’s Springboks are to blame. The gaze of the sporting…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *