Kendall Jenner and Kylie Jenner just get Halloween.

Kylie, 27, took to Instagram on Thursday, October 31, to show off her matching Lizzie McGuire–inspired costume with Kendall, 28. In the clip, Kylie is dressed as Isabella Parigi (played by Hillary Duff) from the Lizzie McGuire Movie, rocking a green leather jacket just like the character. She paired the top with a fitted miniskirt featuring sheer fabric that perfectly layered over her fishnet tights.

For glam, Kylie donned a full beat including pink lips, filled-in eyebrows and long lashes. Her brunette strands were styled in a bouncy blowout, just like Isabella’s was in the movie.

Kendall stole the show in a blonde wig, looking just like Duff, 37, while embodying Lizzie. She rocked the exact outfit Lizzie wore in the movie: a sparkly purple crop top featuring a silver zipper, an embellished jacket and low-waisted pants featuring the same glitter-flecked floral pattern.

“This is so legendary! The way this movie had us all in a chokehold!” Jaclyn Hill wrote, as Natalie Halcro added, “Cutieeeeeessss haha 😍😍😍.” Mom Kris Jenner added heart eye emojis.

This isn’t the first time Kendall and Kylie have won Halloween with nostalgic costumes. Last year, they dressed up as Sugar and Spice from the 1995 movie Batman Forever. Kylie looked unapologetically hot in a corset featuring skulls, a studded choker and a wild red-and-black wig, while Kendall layered on the feathers in a sheer robe and lace-up bodysuit.