David de Gea’s future at Manchester United has been described as “in the balance”; Spaniard is out of contract at the end of the month with a new deal at Old Trafford yet to be signed off

When Petr Cech was embarking on the short trip across London to join Arsenal from Chelsea, his captain John Terry claimed the then 33-year-old would be worth up to 15 points a season to the club he was joining.

Cech, granted the honour of being inducted into the Premier League Hall of Fame in May, stands alone as the most successful goalkeeper in the Premier League’s history.

His 202 clean sheets in the competition – 163 of them for Chelsea – is a record that is likely to stand the test of time.

But, still a year younger than when Cech made that switch, where would David de Gea rank on the list of goalkeepers to have graced the English game?

In reference to Terry’s quote, some Manchester United fans may cruelly argue the Spaniard has similarly contributed to 15 points – but at his side’s expense.

The De Gea conundrum

In a career so far spanning 540 appearances in English football since arriving in 2011, De Gea has made 17 errors leading to goals in the Premier League – the most by any Spanish goalkeeper in the competition’s history. But given the sheer volume of games, is that a particularly high number?

If this is to prove his final week in English football, his 12-year stay at Old Trafford will be rather hard to define. Last season brought the Golden Glove as well as breaking Peter Schmeichel’s clean-sheet record.

When De Gea received the award, Roy Keane – at the forefront of his detractors – told Sky Sports: “United had to improve from last year, they were so bad defensively.

“They’re all patting him on the back. I’d move him on quickly, De Gea. He’s not going to get United back lifting trophies, absolutely not. United were bound to improve from last year so everyone patting him on the head is ridiculous. It’s his job.”

That much is true, but it is not as if those in front of him have exactly excelled on a consistent basis during a decade-long search for another Premier League title.

Why keeping faith in De Gea could be rewarded

De Gea will reflect on a job well done after registering more shut-outs than his peers for the second time. His 16 clean sheets during the course of last season not quite eclipsing the 18 he managed during the 2017/18 campaign.

Defining his impact, and the widely held belief that Erik ten Hag has a vision for United that has a different profile guarding his goal, is not easy to pinpoint. It is a verifiable conundrum.

The 32-year-old has his critics, some as high-profile as his errors, that have contributed to the viewpoint that De Gea’s is a problem position that United must prioritise this summer.

There is the added tax of being the goalkeeper for one of the biggest club’s in the world – as the highest-paid ‘keeper in the world in addition to being the highest-paid Spanish footballer.

This doesn’t always equate to success, in the same way that his proud clean sheet record doesn’t tell the full story. His supporters will, however, point to 12 years of service during a tumultuous period in United’s history.

From 2011 up to the present day, he has been the one constant; deemed good enough to arrive as Edwin van der Sar’s successor under Sir Alex Ferguson as a skinny 20-year-old.

Signed for a British record fee for a goalkeeper of approximately £18.9m, De Gea had excelled at Atletico Madrid, where his goalkeeping coach Diego Diaz said in 2010: “Even though he’s still growing physically and mentally, he’s already on the road to becoming one of the best ‘keepers around. Any other outcome would be a disappointment.”

Growing into the role with that ringing endorsement, he has remained United’s No 1 under David Moyes, Louis van Gaal, Jose Mourinho, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, Ralf Rangnick and – until now – Ten Hag.

His potential departure is also laced in confusion. It was assumed there would come a point where his future would be clarified.

The season came to an end without any fanfare over a final game for the club. There have been very tenuous reports of interest ‘from Saudi Arabia’ but nothing concrete. No smoke, and so no fire.

But heading into the final week of his contract, his future has come sharply into focus. For United, it is use it or lose it time.

It has emerged they want to keep him, but on considerably reduced terms.

Discussions remain open between club and player

On Tuesday, United supporters blocked the entrance to the club’s Megastore to protest against the Glazer family amid the ongoing ownership saga.

To add to the chaos, it emerged via The Athletic that the club reneged on an agreed proposal to extend De Gea’s contract.

It was reported that the player agreed to a drastic reduction on his £375,000 per week wages – but the club did not sign the contract.

De Gea is committed to staying at Old Trafford for as long as he was wanted, but the subsequent offer on the table of an even lower salary now tests his resolve.

De Gea joined Manchester United from Atletico Madrid in 2011

The player has every right to question how these final months have played out. While he is not at quite the same level as in his pomp, should a player of over 450 appearances for United warrant greater respect?

Those that may stand on both sides of the debate may agree the process through which we have arrived at the present day, with De Gea on track to become a free agent, is symptomatic of the club’s current malaise.

Back in February, De Gea made history with his 400th Premier League appearance for United, with no non-British player making more for one club.

But allowing for his contract to run down at 32, viewed still as a good age for a goalkeeper of 45 international caps, smacks of poor planning. At the very least, United have kicked the can down the road when it has come to addressing the goalkeeper issue, despite other areas still being unresolved.

Why Ten Hag would want a change at No 1

When Ten Hag arrived a year ago, it was immediately identified – based on his preferred style of play at Ajax – that De Gea’s face wouldn’t fit. His profile didn’t meet the criteria based on his new manager’s possession-based approach.

There were immediate teething issues, as witnessed in the 4-0 humbling at Brentford.

The first half at the Gtech Community Stadium was a ‘disasterclass’ for De Gea and for Harry Maguire, but the result of not playing to the strengths of those at Ten Hag’s disposal.

Blame could be apportioned on both sides, and the United boss has acknowledged there will be pain along the way as he seeks to mould United into his image. Lessons were learned as the goalkeeper was instructed to kick long against high-pressing teams.

United are looking at other options including Diogo Costa

United have made initial contacts with Inter Milan over Andre Onana, and have looked at Brentford’s David Raya and Porto’s Diogo Costa. Ten Hag publicly backed De Gea, but the Dutchman never guaranteed he would be No 1 next season even if he had stayed.

Dean Henderson is back at the club after his loan spell at Nottingham Forest ended, so United could opt to promote from within.

For De Gea, every stellar performance has been decontextualized by lapses in concentration. Ten Hag retains a desire to build a side comfortable throughout in build-up play, with a goalkeeper that does not hesitate when it comes to coming off his line.

We remember how Said Benrahma’s shot was allowed to go through him in defeat at West Ham, how he was culpable to some degree on all three of Sevilla’s second-leg goals to knock United out of the Europa League.

There was then criticism of how Ilkay Gundogan’s second in United’s FA Cup final loss against Manchester City was allowed to travel so far without De Gea readjusting his feet.

In the crucial moments, in the key games, how often has he been the man for the big occasion?

Quite fittingly, in what could prove his final appearance at Old Trafford, there was a reminder of De Gea at his best when very little was on the line.

Fulham were leading when De Gea saved Aleksandar Mitrovic’s penalty in front of the Stretford End. It is a mere sidenote in a draining season, but United would go on to win the game.

Erik ten Hag has publicly backed De Gea on a number of occasions

Ten Hag said afterwards: “I think it shows even at that age, you can progress. It was a great save.

“A real step up in his performance and I think that it’s similar for our team during the season, good is not good enough and you have to do better.

“It was a great save in the right moment in the game because, 2-0 down, then it’s going to be difficult to win the game.”

De Gea’s desire is to remain playing at the highest level. Taking another lucrative payday in Saudi Arabia would be an acceptance that those days are behind him.

But in allowing his contract to expire, perhaps only then will the player be fully appreciated in less hostile surroundings, emerging as one of the world’s best as his goalkeeping coach Diaz once foretold.

United had other fires to fight this summer. Beyond the protracted takeover, there is the toing and froing with Chelsea over Mason Mount.

Andre Onana shows good footwork for Inter Milan

There is a desire to recruit at least one new striker, with interest remaining in Atalanta’s Rasmus Hojlund after initial contacts between the clubs.

There is the hope that the transfer budget can be increased by player sales, in conjunction with the futures of captain Maguire, Fred, Scott McTominay and Anthony Martial.

But all that would be pushed lower down the pecking order if the endgame to the De Gea conundrum leaves a vacancy at No 1.

United finished eight points above fifth-placed Liverpool in securing Champions League football last season. Taking into consideration City’s superior goal difference, they were also effectively 15 points off the Premier League summit.

De Gea poses with the Carabao Cup trophy

Was De Gea the difference in adding a top-four berth to Carabao Cup success, or would the gap to City have been closer with a different goalkeeper?

Having played every minute, he certainly played his part – but the extent to which his presence defined United’s fate still lingers.

For all of United’s myriad issues to be resolved, the absence of a first-choice stopper would emerge as Ten Hag’s top priority and only concern.

Source: skysports